Talk:Excalibur/@comment-75.69.77.10-20120115020052/@comment-222.125.40.4-20120127045338

It all depends on the prefix. I think its most likely you got a Broken Excalibur, which deals 30-odd damage, no better than the night's edge. On the contrary, your friend might have a Legendary Excalibur, deals 60-odd damage. That explains it.