Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4640423-20130113005714/@comment-5995685-20130115071629

if your tanking, as long as your wearing the Cross Necklace then you can chose whatever for the rest. But if your going up against something like the destroyer or Skeleton Prime, where your getting hit quite often, then the Star Cape and Obsidian shield (so you aren't constantly getting knocked away) are best.