Talk:Pumpkin Moon/@comment-3967802-20131028070613

It seems like the Pumpking isn't dropping anything except Spooky Wood (and candy apples) for me. I got to the 8th wave and so I've definitely beaten the Pumpking twice before dawn. Is anyone else having this problem? I've been beating him solo, so maybe that's the issue...? Or maybe he doesn't drop a significant item every time? :-(

I've gotten a couple of things from the Headless Horseman after dawn (he doesn't seem to leave, so I have time to finish him off.) I've also gotten the Scarecrow outfit a couple of times and a few goody bags.