Talk:Terraria: Otherworld

Appropriate?
Okay, so with the announcement of this game, an interesting question has come up: Is this a wiki for Terraria: The Game or the Terraria Franchise? I don't actually know how to answer this myself, so I'm leaving this open to a standard wiki vote, and I'd like the input of all users who see this page (especially Curse staff, as they may have their own plans to deal with new games in the series) but I expect input and justifications, not blind support. More information on this game is going to come out and more people are going to start acting on it, so we need to decide early if this info is going to be recorded here or directed to its own wiki.

I'll leave it up to votes for a few days before any action is taken. Until then, this page is essentially protected. --Gearzein (talk) 21:43, 16 February 2015 (UTC)


 * Well, if we have a page for Terraria 2, then probably this Gamepedia is for the franchise Terraria. --LuisYKW2 (talk) 19:53, 16 February 2015 (Brasilia time zone)


 * I think that we should keep Terraria: Otherworld information off this wiki. If we were to have this be a wiki for both games, we would have to state on each page which game it refers to, and it would get confusing when searching for a specific item. As Loki stated in the post announcing the game, "We also plan to launch a full site and community for Terraria: Otherworld at a future date/closer to launch." If they are going to launch an entirely different site and community to go with this game, it should have its own wiki as well.  Chrisf1020  (talk)  07:35, 17 February 2015 (UTC)


 * I think that this wiki should just be for Terraria 1, but it should have a page for Terraria: Otherworld, and links to pages on a separate wiki for Terraria: Otherworld. --Jcourt325 (talk) 6:55, 17 February 2015 (UTC)


 * It's your wiki and we will abide by your feelings on the matter, but i find that keeping franchises together on one wiki works best. We do want to gear up for the new game so i'd appreciate your final decision as soon as possible. We can do either: add the new content to this wiki, either with appropriate real estate on the main page and useful categories, or a new namespace for the new game (still with some main page changes to point to it), or a totally separate wiki. — Game widow (talk) 18:17, 17 February 2015 (UTC)


 * I'd have to agree with Game widow. Keep this wiki with the Terraria franchise. Much like how Wowpedia is, it's focused on the Warcraft franchise: including the books, the role-playing games (Warcraft III)... not just the MMORPG itself. Some conflicts may be ahead, but we'll always find a way around them. 21:48, 17 February 2015 (UTC)


 * The real question when combining or splitting wikis for a franchise are how similar those games are. If you have to basically copy/paste all info to a new wiki, because it is the same, its just a waste of time. However, if you have to write each page twice, one for the first game in the franchise and one for the second game, it just becomes messy. Having seen the short preview for the game I believe the first case applies here. All mechanics and even the items seem to be the same, only with updated graphics. Therefore, I think it would be best not to make separate wikis. Having to refer to which version it applies shouldn't be a problem, we already do the same for the console and mobile versions. Of course, if future previews show that there are in fact significant differences between the two versions, it would be better to split it. However, for now I suggest making a page about the new version and just keep it on this wiki till more information is available. --0icke0 (talk) 00:11, 18 February 2015 (UTC)

will this replace regular terraria???
 * No. Gearzein (talk) 19:49, 17 February 2015 (UTC)