Pumpkin Pie

Like the Bowl of Soup, Pumpkin Pie grants you the Well Fed buff upon consumption, which increases the following stats:

+1 defense +1% critical hit chance on all attacks +5% melee speed +5% melee damage +10% magic damage +10% movement speed

The buff lasts for 15 minutes (as opposed to the 10 minutes granted by Bowl of Soup), but can be cancelled at any time by right-clicking the icon or death.