Forum talk:Video Policy Discussion/@comment-4085927-20120225070144

Version 1 will cause more issue, the users here do clean up the vandalism but very few use RC so they wont even notice its happening. Many people also think their videos are the best but they really suck. I know many think people updating over other peoples videos is just something that happened in the past but that's not quite true, it only stopped once hero request i run my bot and protect all videos so people couldn't update them.

I think version 2 is the best as most people have no idea on how to find out if a video has been updated without going to its page.

Version 3 seems a bit constrained, there will be a number of cases where its a waste of time to get the full communities opinion on a video. ie. a page has no video and the one presented is of excellent quality. Seems sort of pointless to wait and leave a page without needed content when its clear its a good video.

Btw Sannse when you allow this to happen you will need to get a bot to un-protect all videos on the wiki. As like 98% are set to sysop protection.