Forum talk:Video Policy Discussion/archive/@comment-4026446-20120210085521

I think it is a perfectly reasonable request that if the youtuber adds videos to the wiki they either support the wiki or are indifferent. There are dozens of youtubers who do this. To specifically try to force in 1 youtuber who have very strong ties with the other wiki is to try and force traffic to the other wiki. Specific youtubers should not be the topic of this discussion. It should be what is best for the wiki not directly trying to get 1 specific youtubers videos on the wiki. I thought that was exactly why this talk was started. Now I see a lot of talk about 1 youtuber. That should not be the issue at all. It should be about what is best for the wiki without promoting personal agendas of your favorite youtubers.

This I believe is wrong. Lets keep the discussion on the policy and how it affects the health of the wiki without promoting personal favorite youtubers. after the policy is outlined then we can talk about what youtubers videos qualify.

No matter who they are promoting youtubers who promote the competition is a bad decision regardless of who they are.